In the previous post, we talked about using Coverdell ESA’s as a method of saving for college. While this is a useful tool, there’s another tool that may be better – the 529 Plan. What are some of the similarities and differences between the two?
As with ESAs, contributions to a 529 Plan are not deductible for federal tax purposes. However, earnings are tax-deferred. And if used for qualified education expenses, accumulated funds can be withdrawn tax free. And as a custodial account, UTMA accounts let you save in a child’s name, tax free!
One feature that some 529 Plans have which all ESAs don’t are state tax benefits. Some state plans offer an upfront deduction on contributions, while others make withdrawals exempt from state taxes in addition to the federal tax exemption.
Contribution Limits And Requirements
Each state has their own 529 Plan, but investment in a state’s plan doesn’t restrict you to using the funds for a school in that state. You can live in Texas, invest in a California plan, and send your beneficiary to college in New York.
With the inflation rate for college rising faster than the normal inflation rate, some people want to save more than the $2,000 annual limit for ESA’s. The 529 Plan has a much larger limit. You can contribute up to the limit set by the state offering the plan, which is usually over $300,000 per beneficiary.
And unlike ESA’s, there are no income limitations for those who want to contribute to a 529 Plan.
Unlike ESAs, in which beneficiaries must use the assets by the time they reach age 30, there is no age limit on the use of 529 Plan assets.
But although ESA funds can be used for elementary, secondary, and post secondary school expenses, funds in a 529 Plan can only be used at a post secondary school.
And like the ESA, earnings in a 529 Plan that aren’t used for qualified expenses will be subject to income tax and a 10% penalty.
While ESAs are more flexible with the type of investments you can choose, 529 Plans are more restrictive. Funds can only be invested in portfolios established by the plan.
Each portfolio will have different investment objectives, but there will usually be an option for a portfolio whose asset allocation becomes more conservative as the beneficiary reaches college age. In addition to this, you’re allowed to change the investment strategy once a year.
Not only is the 529 Plan a great savings tool for college – another benefit is that it can be used to reduce the size of your estate. Contributions of up to $13,000 per year can be made to the 529 Plan without paying a gift tax. Once completed, this money is removed from your estate.
And since you can treat a contribution as being made over a five-year period for gift tax purposes, you can contribute a lump sum of $65,000 in the first year and still avoid gift tax. With this method, the money and its future appreciation will be removed from your estate faster.
So because of the larger contribution limits, state tax benefits, and ability to remove assets from your estate, I think the 529 Plan has the advantage over the Coverdell ESA.
What do you think? Do you have a 529 Plan? Do you like them better than Coverdell ESA’s?